The theory gained traction after Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy endorsed the idea of a Super Bowl proposal, calling it the ultimate fairytale ending. Fans have also pointed out that Kelce’s teammate Mecole Hardman Jr. proposed to his girlfriend after last year’s championship win, fueling speculation that Kelce could follow suit.

Kelce added that Swift reached out to him, leading to their first date in New York. He later confirmed on The Pat McAfee Show that the date took place around one month before Swift’s first appearance at a Chiefs game that September. Swift also opened up about the relationship in a December interview with TIME .

Taylor Swift showed up to Super Bowl LIX in “Style,” but the game could have gone better for her and the Chiefs.